{{status_msg}}

Home Prices Are Softening. What Buyers Can Negotiate Now

Posted:

November 17th

  • Share on Facebook

For over three years, the average home in America consistently sold for more than what it did a year earlier, month after month. That pattern has finally changed. Data from October shows that the median sale price has slightly dipped below the same period last year, marking the first annual decrease since the spring of 2023. Concurrently, the supply of homes for sale has reached its highest peak since early 2020, while pending sales have dropped to levels not seen in more than ten years, excluding the early pandemic. Roughly 20% of properties currently listed have experienced a price reduction.

However, the challenge persists as borrowing costs have risen once again. The average rate for a 30-year fixed mortgage has returned to the mid-7% range recently, despite a brief period of improvement. While buyers are gaining some negotiating power, many households may find monthly payments to be a financial hurdle.

This scenario creates a distinct opportunity. Sellers are now receiving fewer offers and experiencing prolonged time on the market, meaning that the list price and terms being offered have become more of a starting point for negotiation rather than a final figure. If you are actively searching for a home this winter, here's what might be negotiable and how to approach discussions with your real estate agent and lender.

Understanding the Implications of a Small Price Decrease

A national reduction of less than half a percent is not indicative of a market crash, nor does it suggest that prices are declining across the board. Some high-end coastal areas with minimal inventory continue to show robust gains, whereas several major metropolitan regions in the South and West have recorded price declines of several percentage points from last year. The conditions in your specific market carry far greater significance than national averages.

The national statistics highlight a shift in market dynamics. When homes linger on the market longer and an excess of listings challenge a dwindling pool of buyers, sellers tend to become more open to negotiations. This openness can manifest not only in price adjustments but also in the terms of the sale.

Price is Just One Aspect of Negotiation

Many buyers concentrate solely on the purchase price, but in a high-interest environment, it is crucial to consider how monthly payments and upfront cash requirements impact your financial situation. A minor reduction in price might only marginally lower your loan amount. Alternatively, reallocating that money can yield better benefits for your budget. Common points of negotiation in a slower market may include:

  • Offering a purchase price that is lower than the list price
  • A seller credit to assist with closing costs
  • Completion of repairs prior to closing, or a credit in lieu of repairs
  • Seller-paid assistance to lower your mortgage rate
  • A closing date or moving schedule that aligns with your goals
  • Retaining appliances or window treatments with the home purchase

Your agent will have insights into how homeowners in the area are reacting and can help you prioritize which items to include in your offer. The aim is not to request everything available, but to ask for aspects that will greatly benefit your situation.

Selling Credits Can Help Alleviate Financial Strain

Typical closing costs range from a few percent of the loan amount and are added to your down payment. For many first-time buyers, accumulating the necessary cash can be the most challenging aspect of buying a home. A seller credit can cover some of these expenses directly, enabling you to bring less cash to close.

It's important to be aware of limits, as loan programs usually cap how much a seller can contribute, typically between 3% and 9% of the sale price depending on the type of loan and the size of your down payment. Additionally, any credit you receive cannot surpass your actual closing costs. Inquire with your lender early on about what your specific loan permits, ensuring that any requests made in your offer are compliant with these guidelines.

Understanding Rate Buydowns

With interest rates surpassing 7% once again, one valuable offer that sellers may present is assistance with your interest rate. There are two primary options for this.

A permanent buydown involves paying discount points at closing to lower your interest rate for the loan's entire term. Each point costs 1% of the loan amount, and the degree of rate reduction can vary by lender and market conditions. If you plan to remain in the loan for an extended duration, investing in a permanent buydown may provide significant benefits.

A temporary buydown offers reduced payments for the first year or two. In a common structure, the rate drops by two percentage points in the initial year and one percentage point in the second, before returning to the full rate. For instance, on a $350,000 30-year loan at roughly 7.34%, the monthly principal and interest would be about $2,409. With a temporary buydown, payments in the first year would sink to around $1,952 and $2,176 in the second year, before reverting to the total in year three. Covering this arrangement may cost a little over $8,000, a sum a seller could be willing to offer instead of decreasing the price by that amount.

However, a temporary buydown is not a sustainable long-term solution. You need to be prepared for the full payment once the discount period concludes, and lenders generally qualify borrowers based on the full interest rate. Should rates decline later, refinancing could be an option, but the timing and likelihood of that scenario remain uncertain.

Don't Neglect the Inspection Process

During more frantic markets, many buyers forwent inspections or minimized requests to enhance their competitive position. In a slower market, the pressure to relinquish these protections diminishes. A comprehensive home inspection provides insights into the condition of crucial aspects such as the roof, heating/cooling systems, plumbing, electrical setups, and foundation before you finalize your commitment.

If the inspection reveals issues, your agent can advise on whether to seek repairs, negotiate a price adjustment, or request a credit. Credits may be simpler than arranging for seller-managed repairs, as they give you control over who addresses the work and how it gets done, though the best choice depends on the nature of the issue and your loan requirements.

Prepare Your Financing in Advance

Even strong negotiation power is ineffective if your financing lacks stability. A seller considering two offers will often prefer the buyer who seems most likely to finalize the sale. Before seriously engaging in the market, obtain a thorough preapproval instead of a basic prequalification, determine your maximum comfortable monthly payment rather than just a maximum loan figure, and gather loan estimates from multiple lenders. Additionally, clarify how each lender would manage seller credits or buydowns to avoid unexpected surprises later.

Key Questions for Your Agent

  • How long are homes in this area typically on the market, and how frequently do prices see reductions?
  • Would a price reduction, a closing cost credit, or a rate buydown be most beneficial for my budget?
  • In what ways does this particular home's condition and history influence my negotiation approach?
  • What contingencies should I maintain in my offer for my protection?

The Summary

A softer market does not equate to cheaper buying, especially with rising mortgage rates. However, it does provide well-prepared buyers the opportunity to negotiate terms that fit their financial circumstances. With robust financing, a clear understanding of your priorities, and the guidance of your agent and lender, you may be able to secure terms better than what buyers could have imagined in previous years.

Rewritten using AI

Need Help Finding Your Dream Property?

Whether you're buying your first home or upgrading to your forever one, we're here to guide you with expert advice and personalized service.

Free Consultation
24/7 Support
Trusted Experts
Agent
×
McKenzie Dewitt
{{agentDetails.company}}

You are welcome to reach out to us through the contact details provided.

Call   Email